Beyond Prototyping: Additive Manufacturing in Electrical Engineering
Source: Aleksander/stock.adobe.com; generated with AI
For some, 3D printing may still conjure images of quick but unfinished prototypes or plastic mockups. However, that perception is rapidly becoming outdated. 3D printing, a type of additive manufacturing (AM), enables the rapid fabrication of intricate, multi-material electrical parts—from custom enclosures to functional circuit elements—where and when needed.
But as AM moves from the lab to the production floor, new questions arise. How well do the new materials perform? Can printed conductors perform as well or better than traditionally manufactured counterparts? Are AM parts reliable enough for high-frequency, high-voltage, or safety-critical applications?
This article examines AM's potential for electrical design and the technical challenges and limitations that accompany it. But first, a brief look at the current landscape:
Current State of Additive Manufacturing
Modern 3D printers can process high-performance polymers, metals, ceramics, and even functional composites, enabling the production of functional, end-use parts. Manufacturers leverage AM to create everything from lightweight aircraft components and custom medical implants to intricate electronic housings and connectors. Further, AM has expanded the range of possible designs by making it feasible to fabricate highly complex structures that would be impractical or too costly with traditional manufacturing techniques.
AM offers several advantages compared to techniques like injection molding or computer numerical control (CNC) machining. It significantly reduces material waste since parts are built layer by layer with minimal excess. Production times can be slashed from weeks to days, especially for custom or low-volume components. Most importantly, AM provides much-desired design flexibility, allowing rapid iteration and part optimization for performance rather than manufacturability.
While these general advantages offer compelling reasons to adopt AM, the electrical engineering field stands to benefit from even more specific advances. Notably, the rapid development of new materials provides opportunities for electrical design engineers looking to improve traditional fabrication methods.
New Materials for Electrical Applications
While the evolution of AM technology has set the stage for broader adoption, the rapid development of new materials offers innovation for electrical design engineers. The ability to print with advanced polymers, metals, and functional composites enables engineers to create components that were previously out of reach, both in terms of performance and design flexibility.
Advanced Polymers
High-temperature polymers such as polyether ether ketone (PEEK) and polyetherimide (PEI, also known by the brand name Ultem) have become staples in the AM toolkit. These materials offer ideal electrical insulation and can withstand the elevated temperatures often associated with power electronics, connectors, and enclosures. Their chemical resistance and mechanical strength make them a promising choice for manufacturing housings that must protect sensitive circuitry from harsh environments. This gives engineers the ability to print custom, robust insulating components that previously required complex machining or molding.
Metal Printing Innovations
Metal materials have provided a significant advantage for applications where electrical conductivity or mechanical strength is crucial. While copper is known for its conductivity, it can now be printed into intricate shapes for custom busbars, heat sinks, and electrical contacts—all components essential in power distribution and thermal management.
Aluminum is commonly used in casings for smartphones, laptops, televisions, and other electronics because of its light weight, durability, cost, and ability to dissipate heat. However, its higher thermal expansion (35 percent more than copper) can cause more mechanical stress, joint problems, and reliability issues in electrical applications, especially where temperature changes are frequent. For applications requiring dimensional stability and long-term reliability, copper is generally the better choice.
Functional Materials
Perhaps the most exciting elements are the new functional materials designed for AM. Conductive filaments, such as polymers infused with carbon, silver, or other conductive additives, enable the printing of circuit traces, antennas, and sensors within a single build. Magnetic composites allow for the creation of custom inductors, transformers, or electromagnetic shielding tailored to the needs of a particular device. These materials enable electrical functionality to be built into the component structure, simplifying assembly and creating new design possibilities.
As the portfolio of printable materials continues to expand, design engineers are gaining previously unimaginable control over the properties and integration of their components. This innovation in materials science is not just asking what's possible; it's redefining the boundaries of electrical system design.
Technology Advancements Driving Additive Manufacturing
While innovative materials create new possibilities, advanced printing technologies determine how effectively these materials can be used. The printing process's precision, speed, and reliability directly impact electrical components' performance. Several key technological breakthroughs have emerged that make working with these sophisticated materials possible and practical for production environments.
AI and Machine Learning for Print Optimization
Artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) are being harnessed to refine every stage of the AM process. This means smarter software that automatically optimizes print parameters for conductivity, strength, and precision. By analyzing complex geometries and material behaviors, AI-driven systems help ensure reliable results with less trial and error, speeding development cycles and reducing waste.
High-Precision and Microscale Printing
Current 3D printers offer sufficient precision to produce small features, including circuit traces, connectors, and sensor elements, at the microscale. This capability supports applications in consumer electronics, wearables, and medical devices where space constraints are significant. The ability to print at this scale helps integrate electrical functionality into compact designs.
Embedded Electronics and Multi-Material Integration
Multi-material printing capabilities allow for the combination of conductive and insulating materials in a single build process. This technical capability supports the creation of components with integrated conductive pathways, insulation layers, and embedded functional elements. The practical benefits include fewer assembly steps and new design options, such as housings with internal wiring or circuit boards that incorporate shielding directly.
Monitoring and Quality Control
Quality assurance systems in newer AM equipment include monitoring capabilities using thermal imaging and sensor feedback. These monitoring systems track the printing process in real time and can identify potential defects during fabrication. The ability to detect issues during production helps manufacturers meet the quality standards required for electrical components.
The adoption of AM for electrical applications has been gradual rather than immediate. Several technical challenges have slowed implementation in critical electrical applications, though recent developments address these limitations.
Addressing Perceived Challenges in Electrical Applications
AM for electrical systems has faced persistent challenges, but as previously noted, users now have more advanced materials and technology to help overcome those barriers. Because the landscape is changing so quickly, it is essential to address significant past challenges and how recent advancements are having a significant impact.
Challenge: Post-Processing Requirements
When parts emerge from AM systems, they often carry telltale imperfections, such as rough surfaces that would impede fluid flow, internal porosities that threaten mechanical integrity, or material properties that vary depending on build direction. While engineers can optimize printing parameters to minimize these issues, such approaches often remain technology-specific and incomplete.
Despite significant advances in the automation of post-production for some materials, this challenge lingers, and the industry acknowledges that greater automation in post-processing workflows is essential for manufacturing efficiency.
Challenge: Regulatory and Reliability Concerns
AM components have faced skepticism regarding fatigue performance, moisture absorption, electromagnetic interference (EMI), and the absence of universal standards. Consequently, these concerns have made engineers more cautious about using AM in safety-critical and high-reliability electrical applications.
Fatigue Performance
Recent advancements in surface treatments have significantly extended the lifespan of metal AM parts. Techniques like shot peening and low plasticity burnishing create compressive residual stresses that help these components match the durability of traditionally forged materials.
Shot peening bombards the surface with small spherical media (typically metal, ceramic, or glass) at high velocity to create uniform compressive stress. Low plasticity burnishing uses a highly polished ball tool to apply controlled pressure that deforms the surface with minimal plastic flow. Both techniques strengthen metal 3D-printed components by creating a compressed surface layer that inhibits crack formation and propagation, addressing a critical reliability concern for electrical applications subjected to cyclic loading.
Moisture Absorption
New moisture absorption strategies include hydrophobic coatings, optimized printing parameters for reduced porosity, pre-printing drying, and advanced post-processing (e.g., annealing). All these methods improve the durability of polymer-based electrical components.
EMI Shielding
Advanced 3D-printed composites, such as carbon nanotube-infused polylactic acid (PLA) with polyaniline coatings, now achieve EMI shielding effectiveness above 50dB at 10GHz, making them viable alternatives to traditional metal shields.
Industry Standards
The regulatory landscape is maturing, with new standards and qualification methods emerging for AM parts. Organizations are developing comprehensive data on material properties, heat treatments, and process control, while government and industry initiatives are accelerating certification pathways for critical applications.
Challenge: Production Speed and Scalability
AM has traditionally been hampered by slow production speeds for complex or high-volume parts, limiting its competitiveness with conventional manufacturing. Recent advancements, such as multi-laser AM systems, improve production speed by allowing several lasers to work on different areas simultaneously. However, the efficiency gains are uncertain. While more lasers increase speed, the improvement is not perfectly proportional; for instance, a four-laser machine may only be three times faster than a single-laser system due to unchanged recoating times.
The cost-effectiveness of multi-laser setups varies by application and required investment. Additionally, these systems introduce challenges like precise laser alignment and complex inert gas flow management, which must be controlled to ensure part quality matches that of single-laser machines.
Challenge: Material Performance Limitations
AM electrical materials have lagged behind traditional materials like copper and aluminum in conductivity, and suitable high-quality dielectrics and heat-resistant polymers have been scarce. Polymers often lack the thermal properties needed for power electronics.
Conductivity
New 3D-printable copper alloys using oxide-dispersion strengthening (ODS Cu) offer up to 80 percent of the conductivity of pure copper, with high yield strength and fine feature resolution. This process uniformly distributes nanoscale oxide particles throughout the copper matrix, preventing dislocation movement and grain growth at high temperatures while maintaining excellent electrical properties. The resulting material combines the electrical conductivity needed for RF and antenna applications with improved mechanical strength and heat resistance that pure copper lacks.
Dielectrics and Thermal Properties
Proprietary dielectric inks and advanced polymer composites like PEEK and Ultem provide high insulation and mechanical stability, enabling the printing of complex, high-performance electronic devices. PEEK offers excellent electrical insulation with a 1016 ohm-cm volume resistivity and maintains its dielectric properties even at temperatures up to 250°C, making it ideal for high-power applications. Ultem, a high-performance thermoplastic, complements this with dielectric strength and flame retardancy (UL94 V0 rating), which is needed for safety-critical electrical components.
These advancements in materials, processes, and reliability are enabling real-world applications that were previously thought impossible.
Additive Manufacturing Breakthrough Success Stories
While theoretical advancements sound great on paper, real-world applications demonstrate AM's potential for electrical engineering. These pioneering implementations aren't just incremental improvements; they represent fundamental reinventions of what is possible when design constraints are removed and the full capabilities of AM are unleashed.
Optisys: Redefining Antenna Design in Aerospace
Aerospace technology company Optisys leveraged metal 3D printing to change the design and production of satellite antennas (Figure 1). By consolidating over 100 individual parts into a single, integrated structure, they reduced assembly time and potential failure points, improved electrical performance, and reduced weight, which are all critical factors for aerospace applications. This approach enabled rapid design and customization and demonstrates how AM can address engineering and operational challenges in high-stakes environments.
Figure 1: The SLM 500 additive manufacturing system in action, enabling high-precision metal 3D printing for advanced RF and antenna solutions. (Source: Optisys)
MIT: 3D-Printed Electromagnets for Medical Devices
Researchers at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) developed a method to 3D print compact, magnetic-cored solenoids in a single step using advanced multi-material printing techniques. These electromagnets are smaller, more efficient, and more powerful than conventionally manufactured versions, making them ideal for medical equipment such as ventilators and imaging devices. This breakthrough streamlines production but also enables quick production of life-saving components in emergency or resource-limited settings.
Agilent Malaysia: Automating Resilience and Cost Savings
Agilent's Malaysia facility faced the challenge of producing high-risk parts amid potential supply disruptions. The facility became a center of excellence by developing a low-cost, open-source 3D printing platform integrated with IIoT sensors, AI vision for real-time quality control, and enterprise resource planning (ERP) for automated job scheduling. This AM production system achieved an 83 percent reduction in part costs and a 75 percent cut in lead time, underscoring how AM can drive efficiency in modern electronic manufacturing.
These examples represent just a taste of the possibilities emerging as AM matures. Looking at the trajectory of both technology and implementation, we can now envision a clearer path forward for electrical engineering applications.
The Path Forward
The transformation of AM from a prototyping technology to a production-ready solution marks a pivotal shift for electrical engineering. As material innovations, printing technologies, and quality assurance methods continue to mature, AM is positioned to fundamentally change how we design, produce, and deploy electronic systems.
From space-saving antennas to integrated electromagnetic components, the successes highlighted in this article demonstrate that AM isn't just an alternative to conventional techniques; it enables entirely new approaches to solving electrical engineering challenges.
The ongoing advancements in material conductivity, thermal performance, and reliability address historical limitations, opening doors for wider adoption across critical applications. For engineers, AM offers the rare combination of design freedom, rapid production, and enhanced functionality they are looking for.